Since Hemlock dinged 80, I’ve had an opportunity rarely afforded the plentiful DPS classes. Several friends and friends of friends all had alts ding at pretty much the same time, so we’re all going to heroics college together. In a world of EZ-mode, over-geared 15-minute speed heroic runs, we’re actually having to formulate strategies and actively plan our way through heroics. It has been a great deal of fun, making WoW feel like a whole new game. This is, of course, especially true in my case because my main has a double major in healing and tanking. Just walking in and laying waste with the mightiest of pew-pews I can imagine is strange and different.
So as a two-day old level 80 hunter, I have rather spotty gear. My armory profile is a rainbow coalition of blues, greens, and a couple of easy-to-grab purples. Nonetheless, I’ve made good gear choices with what I’ve had to work with. I’ve reached the hit cap with gear, talents, and enchants. I’m a Beast Master hunter for RP reasons, but I’m within 150 DPS of what I could theoretically be doing with the cookie cutter Survival spec. I’ve theory-crafted my build and pet with spreadsheets to pick the best possible spec for my current gear. I’m safely above the “huntard” threshold.
Last night, our little heroics crew ran through UK and Nexus. We wiped a few of times in Nexus, but I think that was mostly down to trying to approach the instance the same way that we would with our mains. We picked up a healer outside our little group but someone who was nonetheless well known and well regarded by everyone in the group. She healed her butt off, and we definitely needed a lot of healing.
After wrapping up Nexus, we toying with idea of a normal ToC run for gearing up and our healer started looking at our gear scores.
“[Mage], you’re geared for Naxxramas already.”
“Wow, [druid], you’re ready for ToC-25!”
I’m cringing. I know what’s going to happen next. She’s going to look at my gear score.
“Hemlock, we really need to gear you up.”
Now, I don’t dispute this. I have an average iLevel in my gear of 174 or so. I could use some work. I’m less geared than Besom was when she started healing instances, but I’m also having no real problems dropping monsters with the big bad skull mark on them. Nonetheless, objective data is what matters. How I feel about how I’m doing is irrelevant. That’s why I have Recount.
A quick glance at Recount showed that I was above 2000 DPS on almost every fight. (Grand Magus Telestra gave us all real problems, knocking each of our DPS down by around 500.) Overall, I was the top damage dealer, and spot checking individual battles in the logs, I was almost always top slot for DPS. I didn’t really see a fight where I was lower on the meter than second place, and there were only two fights that I noticed where the tank did more damage than I did.
Please don’t misunderstand. This isn’t about e-peen. I’ll admit to being a noob and scrub. Nonetheless, my group downed the bosses without too much loss of gold in repair bills. Our paladin picked up some rather nice plate armor, and I even got the Drake Mounted Crossbow from Igvar “I’ll-Paint-My-Face-With-Your-Blood” the Plunderer. By all counts, it was a successful dungeon run. I just think there’s a larger point to be made here about gear score.
Gear score definitely tells a story, but it’s not really the whole story. You can have a full set of iLevel 200+ epics, but if you’re not hit-capped, then that’s a problem. You can have an intelligent set of gear with great enchants, but if you don’t know a proper shot/spell priority, then that’s a problem. You can know what you’re doing on a stand-in-one-place DPS race like Patchwerk, but if you can’t react on the fly when things go wrong, that’s a problem. If you treat gear score as anything other than a convenient but often flawed measurement, then you’re cruising for a Fail PUG.
Unfortunately, I’m increasingly seeing posts in Trade Chat that look something like this:
LFM for H UK (daily). Min gear score of X required.
And, frankly, that’s a bit retarded. No, don’t tank a heroic until you’re defense capped. No, you’re probably not pulling your weight as a DPS until you’re pulling down 1500-1700 DPS. But you don’t need a full set of Naxx gear to go kill Ingvar. You just don’t.
I’m hoping that the new auto-LFG/random dungeon features coming in patch 3.3 will help out a little bit with this, but until I see the end result, I’m going to have nightmares of people getting kicked for not measuring up to some arbitrary line.
Just to clarify, no one in my group was upset with me about my gear score. They were almost certainly looking at the same Recount data I was. The above anecdote is simply intended to show how gear score seems to pop up everywhere and all the time.